Best Shelter Island Heights Hotels On The Beach
-
Best-rated
-
Private beach
Seven Resort Style Inn Near Beach
7 Stearns Point Road
1.3 km (0.8 mi) from city center
- Picnic area/ Tables
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Fitness centre
- Saltwater pool
9.8
109 reviews
~
US$270
/ night
Seven Resort Style Inn Near Beach
1.3 km (0.8 mi) from city center
- Picnic area/ Tables
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Fitness centre
- Saltwater pool
Seven Resort Style Inn Near Beach
9.8
109 reviews
From
US$ 270
/ night
-
Beach access
Shelter Island House
11 Stearns Point Road
1.3 km (0.8 mi) from city center
- Picnic area/ Tables
- Free parking
- Housekeeping
- Air conditioning
- Bar/ Lounge area
- Outdoor swimming pool
9.1
10 reviews
~
US$230
/ night
Shelter Island House
1.3 km (0.8 mi) from city center
- Picnic area/ Tables
- Free parking
- Housekeeping
- Air conditioning
- Bar/ Lounge area
- Outdoor swimming pool
Shelter Island House
9.1
10 reviews
From
US$ 230
/ night
-
Beach access
Montauk Blue Hotel
108 South Emerson Avenue
34.9 km (21.7 mi) from Shelter Island Heights
- BBQ facilities
-
Car park
US$ 35 per day
- 24-hour security
- Air conditioning
- Golf course
- Indoor swimming pool
8.9
478 reviews
~
US$130
/ night
Montauk Blue Hotel
34.9 km (21.7 mi) from Shelter Island Heights
- BBQ facilities
-
Car park
US$ 35 per day
- 24-hour security
- Air conditioning
- Golf course
- Indoor swimming pool
Montauk Blue Hotel
8.9
478 reviews
From
US$ 130
/ night
Shelter Island Heights Hotels on the Beach with Balcony
-
Beach access
Avonlea
597 Corn Neck Road
67.3 km (41.8 mi) from Shelter Island Heights
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Leisure/ TV room
- Sun terrace
9.8
94 reviews
~
US$209
/ night
Avonlea
67.3 km (41.8 mi) from Shelter Island Heights
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Leisure/ TV room
- Sun terrace
Avonlea
9.8
94 reviews
From
US$ 209
/ night
-
Great deal
-
Beach access
La Quinta By Wyndham Stonington-Mystic Area
349 Liberty Street
55.1 km (34.2 mi) from Shelter Island Heights
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Fitness centre
- Heated swimming pool
8.5
422 reviews
~
US$79
/ night
La Quinta By Wyndham Stonington-Mystic Area
55.1 km (34.2 mi) from Shelter Island Heights
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Fitness centre
- Heated swimming pool
La Quinta By Wyndham Stonington-Mystic Area
8.5
422 reviews
From
US$ 79
/ night
Holiday Inn Express Hartford South - Rocky Hill By Ihg
20 Waterchase Drive
70.4 km (43.8 mi) from Shelter Island Heights
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Fitness centre
- Outdoor swimming pool
8.5
430 reviews
~
US$101
/ night
Holiday Inn Express Hartford South - Rocky Hill By Ihg
70.4 km (43.8 mi) from Shelter Island Heights
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Fitness centre
- Outdoor swimming pool
Holiday Inn Express Hartford South - Rocky Hill By Ihg
8.5
430 reviews
From
US$ 101
/ night
Cheap Hotels in Shelter Island Heights On The Beach
-
Guest favorite
-
Beach access
Home2 Suites By Hilton Long Island Brookhaven
101 Boulevard East
52.4 km (32.5 mi) from Shelter Island Heights
- BBQ facilities
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Fitness centre
- Heated swimming pool
9
543 reviews
~
US$195
/ night
Home2 Suites By Hilton Long Island Brookhaven
52.4 km (32.5 mi) from Shelter Island Heights
- BBQ facilities
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Fitness centre
- Heated swimming pool
Home2 Suites By Hilton Long Island Brookhaven
9
543 reviews
From
US$ 195
/ night
-
Private beach
Winnapaug Inn
169 Shore Road
54.6 km (33.9 mi) from Shelter Island Heights
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Golf course
- Pool with view
8.2
740 reviews
~
US$109
/ night
Winnapaug Inn
54.6 km (33.9 mi) from Shelter Island Heights
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Golf course
- Pool with view
Winnapaug Inn
8.2
740 reviews
From
US$ 109
/ night
-
Private beach
Inn At Harbor Hill Marina
60 Grand Street
30.3 km (18.8 mi) from Shelter Island Heights
- Free parking
- Housekeeping
- Air conditioning
- Welcome drink
- Spa & wellness centre
- Sun loungers
9.4
182 reviews
~
US$206
/ night
Inn At Harbor Hill Marina
30.3 km (18.8 mi) from Shelter Island Heights
- Free parking
- Housekeeping
- Air conditioning
- Welcome drink
- Spa & wellness centre
- Sun loungers
Inn At Harbor Hill Marina
9.4
182 reviews
From
US$ 206
/ night
Pet Friendly Hotels in Shelter Island Heights on The Beach
Kenny'S Tipperary Inn
432 West Lake Drive
34.7 km (21.6 mi) from Shelter Island Heights
- BBQ facilities
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Golf course
- Heated swimming pool
8.2
584 reviews
~
US$99
/ night
Kenny'S Tipperary Inn
34.7 km (21.6 mi) from Shelter Island Heights
- BBQ facilities
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Golf course
- Heated swimming pool
Kenny'S Tipperary Inn
8.2
584 reviews
From
US$ 99
/ night
-
Beach access
Sun And Sound Montauk
22 Soundview Drive
34.5 km (21.5 mi) from Shelter Island Heights
- BBQ facilities
- Free parking
- Housekeeping
- Air conditioning
- Vending machines
- Seasonal outdoor pool
9
241 reviews
~
US$187
/ night
Sun And Sound Montauk
34.5 km (21.5 mi) from Shelter Island Heights
- BBQ facilities
- Free parking
- Housekeeping
- Air conditioning
- Vending machines
- Seasonal outdoor pool
Sun And Sound Montauk
9
241 reviews
From
US$ 187
/ night
-
Beach access
The Niantic Inn
345 Main Street
29.7 km (18.5 mi) from Shelter Island Heights
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Garden area
8.8
369 reviews
~
US$214
/ night
The Niantic Inn
29.7 km (18.5 mi) from Shelter Island Heights
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Garden area
The Niantic Inn
8.8
369 reviews
From
US$ 214
/ night
The Bentley Hotel Southampton
161 Hill Station Road
23.1 km (14.3 mi) from Shelter Island Heights
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Laundry
- Saltwater pool
9.2
204 reviews
~
US$234
/ night
The Bentley Hotel Southampton
23.1 km (14.3 mi) from Shelter Island Heights
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Laundry
- Saltwater pool
The Bentley Hotel Southampton
9.2
204 reviews
From
US$ 234
/ night
-
Popular choice
-
Private beach
Royal Atlantic Beach Resort
126 S Emerson Ave
35.0 km (21.8 mi) from Shelter Island Heights
- BBQ facilities
- Free parking
- Housekeeping
- Air conditioning
- Golf course
- Heated swimming pool
7.7
942 reviews
~
US$113
/ night
Royal Atlantic Beach Resort
35.0 km (21.8 mi) from Shelter Island Heights
- BBQ facilities
- Free parking
- Housekeeping
- Air conditioning
- Golf course
- Heated swimming pool
Royal Atlantic Beach Resort
7.7
942 reviews
From
US$ 113
/ night
-
Private beach
Breezeway Boutique Hotel
70 Winnapaug Road
52.9 km (32.9 mi) from Shelter Island Heights
- BBQ facilities
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Golf course
- Heated swimming pool
9.1
164 reviews
~
US$205
/ night
Breezeway Boutique Hotel
52.9 km (32.9 mi) from Shelter Island Heights
- BBQ facilities
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Golf course
- Heated swimming pool
Breezeway Boutique Hotel
9.1
164 reviews
From
US$ 205
/ night
-
Beach access
Sea Crest
2166 Montauk Highway
28.8 km (17.9 mi) from Shelter Island Heights
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
-
Car park
Charges may apply
- Housekeeping
- Air conditioning
- Tennis court
- Outdoor swimming pool
9
283 reviews
~
US$218
/ night
Sea Crest
28.8 km (17.9 mi) from Shelter Island Heights
- Cookware/ Kitchen utensils
-
Car park
Charges may apply
- Housekeeping
- Air conditioning
- Tennis court
- Outdoor swimming pool
Sea Crest
9
283 reviews
From
US$ 218
/ night
Are you in a hurry?
Here is a quick list of Beach Hotels in Shelter Island Heights, selected based on their rating
| Name of hotel | Accommodation Rating | Price, $ | |
| Seven Resort Style Inn Near Beach |
9.8 / 10 (109 Reviews) |
From 270$ | |
| Shelter Island House |
9.1 / 10 (10 Reviews) |
From 230$ | |
| Montauk Blue Hotel |
8.9 / 10 (478 Reviews) |
From 130$ | |
| Avonlea |
9.8 / 10 (94 Reviews) |
From 209$ | |
| La Quinta By Wyndham Stonington-Mystic Area |
8.5 / 10 (422 Reviews) |
From 79$ |